Using Simon's Governing through crime to explore the development of mental health policy in England and Wales since 1983

Cummins, ID ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7814-3835 2013, 'Using Simon's Governing through crime to explore the development of mental health policy in England and Wales since 1983' , Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law, 34 (3) , pp. 325-337.

Preview

PDF Download (131kB) | Preview

Abstract

The reform of the Mental Health Act in 2007 saw the introduction of SupervisedCommunity Treatment Orders (CTOs) in England and Wales. It is argued that this marks a fundamental shift in the rights of those subject to mental health legislation.This paper will explore the developments in mental health policy in the 1980s and1990s that form the backdrop to the introduction of CTOs. It uses Simon’s Governingthrough crime (2007) as a basis to explore the developments in mental health policy that resulted in the final introduction of CTOs. The paper explores the paradox at theheart of mental health policy. This paradox being that while the protections and the rights of the mentally ill have increased in a formal legal sense, this has not resulted inthe achievement of full citizenship that the idealism of the original proponent of the closure of the asylums envisaged.The policy of deinstitutionalisation was based on a series of progressive notionsand explicit rights based approach to the treatment of citizens with mental healthproblems. However, the implication of this policy has not resulted in the end of stigma,marginalisation and discrimination. Many commentators would suggest that the asylums have now come to the community rather than the reverse. The mental health policy response to the failings of community care was one characterised by an increasedmanagerialist culture with a focus on audit and risk. These events are discussed in terms of Cohen’s (1972) notion of a ‘moral panic’. In addition, they are analysed as part ofHall and others’ view of the crisis of legitimacy faced by Welfare States from the early1970s onwards. The eventual result was the introduction of CTOs. This marks afundamental shift in the balance between individuals with mental health problems andthe therapeutic state. It is argued that the fact that such a significant change has beenintroduced in the face of opposition from virtually all the key stakeholders in the areaindicates that the ‘mentally ill’ and the ‘mad’ continue to be a marginalised.

Item Type:	Article
Themes:	Health and Wellbeing
Schools:	Schools > School of Health and Society > Centre for Applied Research in Health, Welfare and Policy Schools > School of Health and Society
Journal or Publication Title:	Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law
Publisher:	Taylor & Francis
Refereed:	Yes
ISSN:	0964-9069
Related URLs:	http://www.tandfonline.com/toc/rjsf20/cu...
Funders:	Non funded research
Depositing User:	ID Cummins
Date Deposited:	18 Jan 2013 10:27
Last Modified:	15 Feb 2022 16:25
URI:	http://usir.salford.ac.uk/id/eprint/28322

Actions (login required)

Edit record (repository staff only)